Exploring Emotion Contagion with “Breathing” Robots

Introduction

In the rapidly evolving field of human-robot interaction, researchers are uncovering novel ways in which robots can influence human emotions. A particularly intriguing question is whether humans can "catch" emotions, such as fear, by engaging with robots that mimic human behaviors. This study aimed to investigate whether holding a robot that simulates varying breathing patterns can influence human emotions, particularly fear.

Method

We built plush robots with motorized ribcages that expanded and contracted to simulate breathing. These robots exhibited three types of breathing patterns: stable (calm) breathing, accelerated (fearful) breathing, and non-moving (control).

Participants held these robots while watching a 90-second fear-inducing video clip from the movie "The Shining". Throughout the experiment, participants’ heart rates (HR) were monitored to determine if the robot’s breathing patterns affected their physiological and emotional responses to the fear stimulus.

Robot Breathing Patterns

  1. Stable Breathing: The robot’s breathing rate was maintained at approximately 14 breaths per minute, simulating a calm state.

  2. Fearful Breathing: The robot's breathing rate increased gradually from 14 to 30 breaths per minute, simulating hyperventilation associated with fear, before gradually returning to 14 breaths per minute.

  3. No Breathing: The robot remained completely still, serving as a control condition.

 
 

Results

Heart Rate Changes: Participants holding the robot exhibiting a fearful breathing pattern demonstrated a significant increase in heart rate compared to those holding the stable-breathing or non-moving robots. Conversely, participants holding the robot exhibiting a stable and calm breathing pattern demonstrated a significantly decreased heart rate when compared to the non-moving control condition. These results suggest that robots exhibiting a rapid and fearful breathing pattern can heighten humans’ fear, whereas a robot demonstrating a stable and calm breathing pattern can reduce humans’ fear. Human physiological responses are therefore guided by the robot’s behavior.

 
 

Discussion

Real-World Applications

These findings have important implications for multiple real-world scenarios:

  • Human-Robot Interaction: Robots can modulate human emotions, highlighting their potential use in therapy, education, and entertainment.

  • Wearable Technology: Integrating simulated breathing movements into wearable devices could enhance desired fear-inducing or thrilling experiences, such as when viewing horror films or gaming.

  • Emotional Support Animals: Understanding how touch and breathing patterns influence emotions raise questions about the effectiveness of emotional support animals in fear-eliciting contexts. Given that animals also experience fear and hyperventilate, they may be ineffective or counterproductive at downregulating humans’ fear during crises in which the animals themselves are also frightened.

Conclusion

Humans can indeed “catch” fear from dynamic robots through touch, which can significantly impacting how we respond to external stimuli. As technology continues to advance, the potential for robots to influence human emotions in both positive and negative ways will become increasingly important. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for developing robots that can effectively support and enhance the human experience.

Researchers:

  1. Zak Witkower (lead), University of Amsterdam

  2. Laura Cang, University of British Columbia

  3. Paul Bucci, University of British Columbia

  4. Karon MacLean, University of British Columbia

  5. Jessica Tracy, University of British Columbia